pile of books
skip main nav
 Ling 131: Language & Style
 

 Topic 12 - Meaning between the lines (Session A) > Top Girls > Task D skip topic navigation

Session Overview
Inference and the Discourse Architecture of Drama
Grice's Cooperative Principle
Practising Gricean Analysis
Top Girls
Conversational implicature and The Dumb Waiter
Gricean Self-Test
 
Useful Links
Top Girls Passage
Readings
 

Top Girls

Task D - Turns 22 - 25

Note: you can find a link the text using under 'useful links' section of the menu on the left

In turn-taking terms, in turns 1-8 we have seen Louise trying to avoid answering Win's questions in spite of the fact that Win needs the answers if she is to help Louise. This kind of pattern is repeated through the extract, foregrounding Louise's discomfort in an activity she must herself have initiated by coming to the agency, and Win's increasing directness in trying to find out why Louise wants to move. Louise is clearly very unhappy in her job, but is refusing to say why.

Now let's look at the end of the extract. Win has managed to get Louise to say that part of the reason she wants to move is for more money, but it is clear that there are other reasons too. So at the end of turn 21, Win asks 'Have you any dependents?' What happens in Gricean terms from then on?

22. LOUISE:

No, no dependants. My mother died.

23. WIN:

So why are you making a change?

24. LOUISE:

Other people make changes.

25. WIN:

But why are you, now, after spending most of your life in one place?

 

Our answer

 

 

 


goto top of page
Next: Conversational implicature and The Dumb Waiter next

Home ¦ Outline ¦ Contents ¦ Glossary