pile of books
skip main nav
 Ling 131: Language & Style
 

 Topic 10 (session A) - Prose analysis > Bilgewater: Foregrounding > Task C

skip topic navigation
Session Overview
Bilgewater: General
Prose Analysis Methodology
Bilgewater: Lexis
Bilgewater: Foregrounding
Bilgewater: Context & cohesion
Bilgewater: Speech & thought presentation
Bilgewater: Grammar
Methodology checksheet
Topic 10 'tool' summary
 
Useful Links
Readings
Bilgewater passage

Bilgewater: Foregrounded features

Task C - Grammatical parallelism - 'same' meaning

Below are three short extracts from the passage.

In each case, spot the parallelisms, specify them, work out their 'local' parallelistic effects and connect these effects to your overall understanding of the passage. Then click on the button after each extract to compare your views with ours. We have provided sentence numbers for ease of reference:

Extract 1

(5) The candidate sat opposite wondering what to do. (6) The chair had a soft seat but wooden arms. (7) She crossed her legs first one way and then the other - then wondered about crossing her legs at all. (8) She wondered whether to get up. (9) There was a cigarette box beside her. (10) She wondered whether she would be offered a cigarette.

Extract 2

(15) Seeing how much you could take. (16) Typical Cambridge. (17) A sign of the times. (18) An hour later and then the second interview - five of them this time behind a table - four women, one man, all in old clothes. (19) That had been a long one. (20) Polite though. (21) Not so bad.

Extract 3

(32) They move their pens about, purse their lips, turn to one another from the waist, put together the tips of their fingers.

We have already commented on the parallelism in sentence 6 in Task B, and so will not consider that here. But there is another general parallelism in sentences 5, 7, 8 and 10, centring on the verb 'wondered', which has a noun phrase or a pronoun referring to the candidate as its subject in each case. The object of 'wonder' in each case is a noun clause. These clauses each relate to relative trivial actions which she is considering, reinforcing the idea that she is hyper-aware and so thinking of trivial things as well as the questions she is being asked. The verb 'wonder' also involves indecision, which thus also contributes to the overall hyper-aware and uncertain attitude of Bilgewater. Sentence 7 also involves a lower-level parallelism, in 'first one way and then the other', which, although it uses the coordinator 'and', not 'but', clearly brings out the attitudinal uncertainty we saw in Task B.

In this example, you probably felt a 'same meaning' parallelistic effect between sentences 16 and 17, and between sentences 20 and 21. First of all, all four of these sentences are odd in that they are grammatically elliptical (they do no have subjects or verbs), something which we will look at a bit more when we look more generally at grammar in the passage. But what makes the two pairs of sentences seem parallel is that the first pair each consist of a short noun phrase and the second pair each consist of an adjective phrase. The first pair have a 'same meaning' relation (negative in both cases), and the second pair have an 'opposite meaning' relation, ending on a positive note. There are also some other, rather trivial, parallelisms (e.g. between 'four women' and 'one man' which we will not bother to discuss.

This sentence has four clauses, each of which has a dynamic verb. The first clause has 'they' as subject of 'move', and 'they' refers to the interviewers. Each of the other clauses has no explicit subject, but it is clear that in all the cases that the interviewers are the subjects to the verbs, and so the actors in the processes involved. The actions involved are small and trivial. In two cases they 'act upon' their own body parts ('lips', 'tips of their fingers', in one they act upon something they possess ('their pens') and in the other case they attend to each other. The effect of this parallelism is to make them appear as a homogeneous group rather than as a set of individuals, who all do trivial things. This in turn can be related to the candidate's heightened perception because of the interview situation.

 

 

 

 


to the top
Next: Task D - sentences 11 and 12 next

Home ¦ Outline ¦ Contents ¦ Glossary