The causal-historical approach to how machine states may get meaning

 

"The attempt to find any naturalistic property or relation with which noncircularly to identify 'mental reference' has come to be called the problem of 'psychosemantics.' ...

The first [approach] is the 'Causal-Historical' approach, in the spirit of Kripke ... and Putnam... , according to which a mental/brain item M refers to a thing X just in case X figures appropriately in M's etiology [etiology: 'assignment of a cause' - COD]. Practitioners of this approach cash the word 'appropriately' in any number of hopeful ways; any successful way will have to account for reference to non- existent things, no small task in itself and multiply hard given that one may not, on pain of circularity, invoke unexplicated propositional-attitude contents."

Lycan's Introducton to Part IV of Mind and Cognition, 2nd Ed. p. 196,7

 

 

Back