Dennett gives a concise outline of the 'brain-in-a-vat' scenario

"Suppose evil scientists removed your brain from your body while you slept, and set it up in a life-support system in a vat. Suppose they then set out to trick you into believing that you were not just a brain in a vat, but still up and about, engaging in a normally embodied round of activities in the real world. This old saw, the brain in the vat, is a favorite thought experiment in the toolkit of many philosophers. It is a modern-day version of Descartes's (1641) evil demon, an imagined illusionist bent on tricking Descartes about absolutely everything, including his own existence."

Daniel Dennett: Consciousness Explained, London, 1993 edition, Penguin, p. 3.

 

This is the start of Dennett's brilliant book - highly recommended.


222 home